Rash of Ohio hate crimes indicative of historical context, culture

Photo: A white girl child rides on a bicycle past as row of swastikas spraypainted on an overpass in Clintonville, Ohio. Photo source: The Columbus Dispatch, Google Images

An overpass in Ohio marred with swastikas,a symbol of white supremacy. | Columbus Dispatch

Ohio, I’m really starting to think you’re trying to win some sort of most hateful place on Earth award. (Just an FYI: There ain’t no trophies for that.)

Anyway, a bunch of messed up stuff has been going on in my home state, especially revolving hate crimes, racism and suicide, which makes all the other things Ohio tries to do—like passing the heartbeat bill, cutting teacher’s salaries and banning gay marriage for the fourth time—seem almost harmless in comparison. Let’s review some recent events from 2012:

Jan. 16: On Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Day, arsonists burned down the home of Mohamed Soltan, Ohio State University student and former OSU Muslim Student Association president, while he and his roommate were sleeping. Both people escaped the blaze, but lost everything they own in the fire and were left homeless. Over the course of the months leading up to the arson, Molton endured racist attacks. People wrote on his garage “Fucking terrorists go home,” keying the same message onto Soltan’s car, as well as “terrorists, leave us alone.” The intimidation tactics also included egging his house, smashing his mailbox, and slashing the tires on his car and the cars of his guests.

Jan. 23: The Lantern, OSU’s student newspaper, ran an ad titled “Former Leaders of the Muslim Student Association (MSA): Where are they now?,” likening Muslims to terrorists and listing the names of several al-Qaida and al-Shabab members who were MSA presidents during their college careers. At the bottom of the ad was the name of the pamphlet, “Muslim Hate Groups on Campus.”

Feb. 19: Clintonville is covered in racist graffiti inlcuding swastikas, the symbol of the Nazi party and white supremacy. A white OSU professor’s car had two swastikas painted on it, and he suspected it was because he has a black son. The message, “Kill all niggers,” was also tagged around the neighborhood, as well as a message written in German that translates to, “Victory to the white race only.”

Mid March: Austin Rodriguez, a 15-year-old openly gay student at Wellsville High School, was put on a ventilator after attempting to take his own life by swallowing over 100 prescription pills. He was bullied at school after coming out as gay.

March 24: Miami University student Michael Bustin and University of Cincinnati student Adam Voegele were attacked in Oxford near Miami’s campus. Four people targeted Bustin and Voegele as they were holding hands while walking home at 2 a.m. from an annual drag show sponsored by Spectrum, Miami’s gay-straight alliance. The attackers screamed derogatory, anti-gay slurs before violently beating the two students. This the second attack at this event in three years.

Photo: A black billboard with white writing reads, "You're so over Over-the-Rhine. Life stinks," as part of a Tidy Cats ad campaign. Photo source: WTOP, Google Images

Tidy Cats's Over-the-Rhine billboard. | WTOP

Early April: As a part of the “NoMorePU” marketing campaign, kitty litter distributor Tidy Cats sponsored a billboard about a mile north of Over-the Rhine that read “You’re so over Over-the-Rhine. Life stinks.” Over-the-Rhine is a predominately black neighborhood in Cincinnati, and the epicenter of the 2001 race riots, poverty and gentrification in the city. The area has also been named the most dangerous neighborhood in the U.S. by the FBI. After public outcry, the billboard was taken down by April 10.

April 2: Xavier University President Fr. Michael Graham announced the Jesuit university’s health insurance policy will “no longer cover sterilizations and contraceptives,” therefore leaving countless faculty and staff unable to access these services under their current insurance plans. Historically, Xavier has covered contraception, despite opposing Catholic doctrine.

April 4: OSU Police detained and drew their weapons on student Mike Newbern for wearing a gun holster to a candlelight vigil for for the racially motivated murders of Trayvon Martin and Shaima Alawadi. Newbern, the president of Buckeyes for Concealed Carry, contends he was demonstrating his support for gun rights by standing at the front of the crowd wearing what turned out to be an empty holster.

Photo: The words "Long live Zimmerman," the shooter of Trayvon Martin, are spraypainted across on OSU's Hale Center. Photo source: Google Images

OSU's defaced Hale Black Cultural Center | Google Images

April 5: The words, “Long Live Zimmerman” were spray painted on the side of the OSU Hale Black Cultural Center. George Zimmerman is the alleged murderer of Trayvon Martin.

April 6: Three swastikas and the word, “niggers” were spray painted on the Hope Mural—a commemoration of the first black president, Barack Obama—in Weinland Park the near OSU in Columbus.

So, things are getting serious at home in Ohio. Very serious. It has become very clear that Ohio is not a safe place for many people, especially people of color and LGBT people. But that’s not really news:

And if we look at the general Tri-State area, the corners of the three states Greater Cincinnati encompasses, there’s more:

Highlights from the flier, titled “Are the homos really harmless????,” include “The promotion of homosexuality and of its acceptance by decent people has been promoted by the destructive forces in this country as another way to remove any semblance of order, of right and wrong, in our society,” and “Their sordid lifestyle deserves nothing but shame and disgust from all normal people and special treatment for perverts will not be tolerated.” It also describes Cincinnati Guerrilla Queer Bar, a group I organized with at home, as:

“a group of local perverts … which purposely flaunt their perversion, filth, and mental disorder on normal people by PURPOSELY targeting normal bars for faggot get-togethers … They seek to ‘queer’ the ‘straight’ bars and clubs according to their mission statement. So is anyone to blame but themselves when a normal person is fed up with this perversion being thrust upon them in such a blatantly offensive way? Sure assault is illegal, but it is safe to say that most normal people are happy to see that some among us will put these social rejects in their place when there [sic] excesses become to [sic] much to tolerate.”

The fliers were posted in response to Covington residents meeting with city officials regarding violence and run-ins with the police that residents felt were motivated by homo-negative attitudes.

And most of this is just since I started blogging Jan. 14, 2009, or something I learned about while blogging. I’m sure there’s been so many more incidents that have gone unreported, that I didn’t hear about (most of these stories received little to no coverage in mainstream news) and/or happened before then. And that’s not even including the people who suffer from or have died from other issues, like no access to health care, or adults who committed suicide.

This is where I come from. These are people I know. These are places I’ve been. We all have stories of being brutalized, attempting suicide, experiencing homelessness or being shipped off to ex-gay therapy. This is the reality. And it’s just jaw-dropping to see it all laid out like that at once.

And thank all things that are good for our community’s responses that look like this:

Photo: Miami University and University of Cincinnati rally against hate crimes. Photo source: Beelisty, Google Images

Miami University and University of Cincinnati rally against a March 2012 hate crime in Oxford. | Beelisty

and this:

Photo: Approximately 200 Ohio State University community members march to a trustee board meeting in response to the recent hate crimes on and near campus. Photo source: Sam Cooler, Plunderbund, Google Images

Approximately 200 Ohio State University community members march to a trustee board meeting in response to the recent hate crimes on and near campus. | Sam Cooler

and this:

Photo: A sign from the Tabby's anti-gay hate crime protest that reads "People from all walks of life  enter this establishment and we like it that way. Expressions of hatred or biogtry will not be tolerated."

This sign appeared at Tabby's bar following the hate crime that occurred there in May 2009.

and this:

Photo: University of Cincinnati community members protest an anti-gay hate crime that happened on campus.

University of Cincinnati community members protest a campus hate crime in March 2009.

All of these incidents cannot be separated. They are an overall reflection on our culture, of our attitudes, our laws and what we teach each other. And we have to work together to change it.

Oppression isn’t perpetuated by bad people. That’s the problem. I’d be hard pressed to even find a truly bad person. It’s not a few bad apples ruining the entire bunch. It’s the people we interact with everyday. The people we work with, we go to school with, we organize with, we live with, we love with. It’s our communities. It’s the choices we make. It’s us.

15 thoughts on “Rash of Ohio hate crimes indicative of historical context, culture

  1. Pingback: Rash of Ohio hate crimes indicative of historical context, culture | QClick Radar

  2. Just a thought on the Austin Rodriguez incident. Sane people do not bully others for their sexual orientation. Sane people do not attempt suicide over said bullying. Not that you specifically linked the two in your post. There is no rational justification for bullying just as there is no rational justification for suicide.

  3. @Madison – Really? You get to the end of this post & what’s most salient in your mind is picking on the suicidal 15 year old?

    • So you’re saying that given the same situation, you or anyone else would have no other choice than to kill yourself?

        • Just like how you intentionally misinterpreted what I was saying? If you don’t have anything to add to the dialogue, don’t add anything at all.

          • There is a difference between suicide due to clinical depression and suicide because you have been harassed, bullied and constantly hurt for long enough that you don’t think it’ll ever end. And I don’t mean to say that people who are suicidal due to clinical depression are any less worthy of help, but I think that we owe it to kids who are put through absolute hell every day in school (a place they cannot choose not to go to) to recognize what a torment it can be and not chalk up their suicide attempt to something individual as opposed to structural. Also, statistically, incredibly high numbers of LGBT youth attempt suicide. Let’s not pretend that means anything but the fact that society must make it easier for them to live their lives.

            • I was frequently harrassed from about the 4th through the 10th grade. In fact my mother wanted me to beat up the neighbor boy over it “before he got too big for me to handle”. My brother was younger so he could not help. But I have no violence in me. Bullying affected me deeply with physical symptoms such as stomach aches and nightmares. I had a couple of friends but they were outcast students too–older guys with learning disabilities who had been held back 2 and 3 times. We did not know we were being bullied. It was just how school was. My parents ended up moving after a principal told my mother, “Well look at her. You can see why she gets bullied”. (I did not know about this for many years.) I was also bullied in Girl Scouts, hit in the stomach by the assistant leader’s daughter on a camp out. I did look different and my parents could not afford the Villager dresses and Weejun shoes other girls wore. And I was somewhat fat, walked with my feet turned out, and real shy. I was also pro-desegregation, in Birmingham, in the suburbs, in the early1960s! The other kids thought I was smart but actually I had a math disability even though I was high verbal. In the 11th and 12th grade, after we moved, I was not bullied. Everyone was more concerned about the 6 African-Americans sent to integrate the school. One girl became my lab partner in chemistry. I made a friend with a “wild child” type girl who had run away to Atlanta for 3 whole days and carved her boyfriend’s name in her arm with a pin, (those days were more innocent) but someone started a rumor that I was a lesbian and she quit speaking to me. I did not even know what a lesbian was then. I never became suicidal but had I not had a family that loved me at the time I might have.

              • I am truly sorry for the things you have went through. I have never suffered from them problems myself but always stood by the people who did. The ignorance of others is just sad instead of trying to get to know people they deem different the rather belittle them and do horrendous things. I hope you was able to overcome those horrible acts against you and thanks for putting this up for others to see =)

  4. Correction, please. The alleged hate crime in Dayton reported at Masque in 2009 1) actually occurred in December 2008, 2) was only “discovered” when it was brought to light by an animal rights website (and twisted several facts in doing so) the organization of which was chaired by the victim, and 3) was NOT I repeat NOT a hate crime. Rather it was a gay-on-gay fight by a boyfriend (attacker) who was upset by the actions of the victim in the club who was allegedly blatantly flirting with another guy. I know this to be the facts here because I personally investigated the incident; I talked to several witnesses and got a copy of the police report. Yes hate crimes are on the rise, but this incident was NOT one of them. FYI, Dayton PD now has an LGBT community liasion officer now, a Lieutenant and out lesbian.

  5. You would think that Ohio was in the Deep South but I don’t think even the worst of Southern bigots are consistently this bad. So don’t stereotype us too much. Even our worst enemies get hospitality.

  6. Pingback: A Rash of Hate Crimes in Ohio: Stories of Oppression, Stories of Hope « In Our Words

  7. Pingback: Kentucky social advocacy groups plan counter protest to Neo-Nazi Hitler rally « Stuff Queer People Need To Know

  8. Pingback: Stigmatization, Low Income Contribute to Unequal Access to Health Care for LGBT People « In Our Words

  9. Pingback: Mailbag: Responses to my Michael Sam editorial in the Cincinnati Enquirer | Stuff Queer People Need To Know

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s